Prosecutors are seeking a 15-year prison sentence for a Calgary father whose young son was left in a skeletal state after enduring nearly two and a half years of physical abuse, a court heard on Tuesday.
Abuse Details
The victim, who was between the ages of six and eight at the time, weighed just 16.2 kilograms (about 36 pounds) when he was admitted to Alberta Children's Hospital on September 29, 2023. According to pediatrician Dr. Jennifer MacPherson, the child was so weak he could barely walk, and his appearance was described as skeletal.
Crown's Argument
Crown prosecutor Zailin Lakhoo argued that Matthew Jason Scott, 41, should receive a 15-year prison term for his role in the abuse. Scott pleaded guilty more than a year ago to charges of failing to provide the necessaries of life, forcible confinement, and aggravated assault. Lakhoo stated that if the judge finds 15 years excessive, a sentence of no less than 13 years would be appropriate.
Defence's Position
Defence lawyer Shaun Leochko countered that a five-year sentence, followed by 24 months of probation, would be suitable and aid in Scott's rehabilitation. Leochko noted that Scott has already spent considerable time in remand, which would equate to a four-year jail term with presentence credit, leaving less than two years remaining in a five-year sentence, allowing for probation.
Circumstances of Abuse
According to an agreed statement of facts read in court when Scott pleaded guilty on March 18, 2025, the abuse occurred between April 2021 and September 2023. Scott and the child's stepmother, Stephanie Alisha Baker, who faces her own charges, subjected the boy to starvation as punishment for infractions such as stealing food. The child was also physically abused, mostly by Baker, and was regularly confined by being tied to a bed rail with duct tape and zip ties, forced to sleep on the floor.
Scott's Apology
Before the judge adjourned the case to October for a sentencing decision, an emotional Scott addressed the court, saying, "I'm deeply sorry for my actions towards my son. I have no excuse for what happened. I really hope that my son will forgive me." Scott remains in custody pending the decision.
The case highlights the severe physical and emotional trauma inflicted on the child, who is now in recovery. The court will determine the appropriate sentence in October.
