The New Hampshire Supreme Court has reversed the murder conviction of Adam Montgomery, the father of a 5-year-old girl who went missing in 2019. The court cited significant trial errors, including improper admission of evidence and jury instructions, and ordered a new trial.
Case Background
Adam Montgomery was convicted in 2024 for the murder of his daughter, Harmony Montgomery, who was last seen in Manchester, New Hampshire. Her body has never been found. The conviction was based largely on circumstantial evidence and testimony from family members.
Court Ruling
In a unanimous decision, the state's highest court found that the trial judge erred by allowing evidence of prior bad acts and failing to properly instruct the jury on the burden of proof. The court also noted that the prosecution's closing arguments were prejudicial.
The ruling overturns the life sentence imposed on Montgomery, who has maintained his innocence. The case will now return to Hillsborough County Superior Court for further proceedings.
Reactions
Harmony's mother, Crystal Sorey, expressed devastation at the decision, saying the family has been waiting for justice. The attorney general's office stated it is reviewing the ruling and will determine next steps.
Legal experts say the reversal underscores the importance of fair trial procedures, even in high-profile cases. The new trial is expected to be scheduled within months.
