The University of Alberta's decision to remove the Casavant War Memorial Organ from Convocation Hall as part of a $7.4 million renovation has drawn sharp criticism from faculty, alumni, and organists who view the instrument as a cherished historical and memorial fixture.
A Monumental Instrument
With thousands of pipes, tall wooden cases, pedals, and keyboards, the Casavant organ is a massive instrument custom-built into Convocation Hall in 1978. Its size and structural integration into the hall make removal complex. The university stated that the organ limits accessibility for individuals with physical disabilities and mobility needs, prompting its removal.
Memorial Status Disputed
The original organ was installed in 1925 and dedicated on Armistice Day to honor soldiers from the First World War. In 1947, it was rededicated and a second plaque added for both World Wars. That organ was sold in 1976, and the current Casavant organ incorporates pipes from the original. The university claims that research with Veterans Affairs Canada shows the formal memorial designation applies only to the 1925 instrument, and it plans to incorporate elements of the organ into the new design.
However, Haley Simons, a U of A alumna from the music department, insists the organ remains a memorial. "The organ has been a central part of the university and the music department," she said. Simons and other advocates urge the university to find a way to keep the organ while improving accessibility. "For universities to so easily discount their history and ignore the research is troubling," she added.
Simons cited a 1978 transcript from the organ's inaugural performance, where then-president Harry Gunning stated, "I would like to emphasize that this new organ is, in fact, a memorial, and reaffirms the dedication associated with the original organ."
Veterans Affairs Canada confirmed the organ is listed in the National Inventory of Canadian Military Memorials but noted that responsibility for memorial changes lies with the owner, and no federal approval is required.
