Sting Weighs In on Toxic Masculinity
Sting has shared his theory behind the apparent rise of toxic masculinity, a term that emerged from the men's movement in the 1980s as a reaction to second-wave feminism. According to the musician, this phenomenon may be linked to a major historic shift: the sharp decline of manual labor.
“I work with my hands every day as a musician, and I’m lucky,” Sting told The Guardian in an interview published Thursday. “It’s a rare thing for modern men to actually use their hands and use their strengths to do anything. We’ve lost something there.”
The singer, born Gordon Matthew Thomas Sumner, continued: “I don’t have any answers, but maybe the toxicity in society at the moment is [a result of the fact] that we’ve lost that direction for our energy, that male strength. It’s rare we have to use it.”
Manufacturing Decline in Numbers
A 2020 report from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics notes a 35% decline in the domestic manufacturing sector from 1979 to 2019 alone. The U.S. economy has also lost 77,000 manufacturing jobs since President Donald Trump was elected in 2024.
A study published earlier this year in Psychology Today noted that “there is not much psychological research” on toxic masculinity, which is associated with traits such as narcissism and hostile sexism. However, the study found that 10.8% of the 15,000 subjects showed “clear signs” of it.
Sting’s Personal Connection
Sting is currently preparing for the London premiere of his musical, The Last Ship, which is inspired by his childhood memories and his relationship with his late father, Ernest Sumner, who worked as an engineer in Wallsend during the shipbuilding boom. Sting fondly recalled the “civic pride” and “community” in his hometown that sprang from these jobs. One of the male characters in the musical ponders losing his identity as a manual laborer: “For what are we men without a ship to complete?”
“Britain’s wealth was created in the coalfields and the steel towns and the mill towns and the shipyards,” Sting told The Guardian. “All of those skills were thrown on the scrapheap … for [former U.K. Prime Minister Margaret] Thatcher’s dream of a service economy.”
Critique of Tech Utopianism
Billionaire tech leaders such as Elon Musk and Sam Altman have frequently suggested that their work in artificial intelligence could create a modern utopia. Critics argue that the exorbitant cost of data centers and their harm to the environment already suggest otherwise.
