The Montreal Canadiens' defensive struggles this season have sparked a debate about the utilization of one of their most physically imposing players. Former Habs enforcer Chris Nilan and defenceman Rick Green, both members of the 1986 Stanley Cup-winning team, are publicly questioning whether the organization is misusing rugged blue-liner Arber Xhekaj.
Scratches Raise Questions About Role and Future
The central point of discussion is Xhekaj's recent string of healthy scratches under head coach Martin St. Louis. The 24-year-old defenceman, who stands 6-foot-4 and weighs 240 pounds, possesses a rare blend of size and a mean streak that recalls the style of former Canadiens captain Shea Weber. This type of player is often seen as crucial for clearing the front of the net and deterring opposing forwards.
Yet, despite the team's acknowledged problems in their own defensive zone, Xhekaj has frequently found himself watching from the press box as a healthy scratch. This pattern has led Nilan and Green, speaking on a bonus episode of The Gazette's Hockey Inside/Out Show with host Stu Cowan, to wonder about the young defenceman's long-term place with the franchise.
Contract and Trade Speculation Emerges
The timing of this scrutiny is significant. Arber Xhekaj is set to become a restricted free agent in the summer of 2025. His uncertain role and frequent benching naturally lead to speculation about his future. The panel on the Hockey Inside/Out Show pondered whether the Canadiens might consider trading the defenceman or if another NHL club could pursue him via an offer sheet.
Teams like the Ottawa Senators, who are in the same division and could value his physical brand of hockey, were mentioned as a potential suitor. The discussion highlights a growing uncertainty surrounding a player who quickly became a fan favourite for his willingness to engage physically and protect teammates.
A Philosophical Dilemma for the Canadiens
The core question posed by the former players is philosophical: do the modern-day Canadiens need and value what a player like Xhekaj brings? His recent on-ice action, including a notable hit on Philadelphia Flyers forward Carl Grundstrom on December 16, 2025, demonstrates the unique element he adds to the lineup.
However, Coach Martin St. Louis's decision to repeatedly make him a healthy scratch suggests a potential disconnect between the player's perceived value and the coaching staff's current deployment strategy. This creates a dilemma for management as they assess their defensive core and plan for both the immediate future and the upcoming contract negotiation.
The debate, fueled by insights from franchise legends, puts a spotlight on how the team balances toughness with its overall tactical system. The resolution of Xhekaj's situation will be a telling indicator of the team's direction.
