Rob Breakenridge argues that the continued silence of certain United Conservative Party (UCP) MLAs on the issue of Alberta separatism is cowardly. Through their refusal to speak out, these MLAs are hiding from both their leader and the voters, he contends.
Premier's Position and Caucus Disunity
Premier Danielle Smith has stated she will vote for Alberta to remain in Canada in the upcoming fall referendum. However, not all UCP MLAs have made similar declarations. While Smith insists her cabinet and caucus support her position, the lack of public statements from backbenchers raises questions.
The Separatist Undercurrent
Although no UCP MLAs have openly declared separatist leanings, it is reasonable to suspect some exist within the caucus. The closest evidence comes from Red Deer MLA Jason Stephan, who penned an op-ed urging Albertans to sign a pro-separatist petition. Stephan subsequently resigned as parliamentary secretary of constitutional affairs.
Smith has publicly rebuked the UCP president for suggesting the party would remain neutral on the referendum question. She emphasized that the party's founding principles support autonomy for Alberta within a united Canada.
Criticism of the Referendum and Silence
Breakenridge criticizes Smith for calling the referendum without a clear mandate, though she cites two petitions as justification. He notes the UCP was re-elected as a federalist party, and Albertans did not vote for separatism in 2023. Smith's advocacy for national unity is commendable, but MLAs who disagree owe their constituents clarity.
The journalist questions why these MLAs are abandoning Canada, undermining the premier's progress with Ottawa, and rejecting the UCP's federalist policy. He also asks who they would prefer to lead a rebranded separatist party.
Polling and Public Sentiment
While support for separatism should not be dismissed, polls show it trailing behind the federal Liberals in Alberta—a party typically unpopular in the province. This suggests separatist sentiment is not a winning political bet.
Despite the lack of public declarations, a loud silence emanates from UCP backbenches. Postmedia reached out to all UCP MLAs last month, asking how they intend to vote on October 19. All 26 cabinet members responded in support of the premier, but none of the other 21 MLAs replied.
Breakenridge concludes that these MLAs are failing their constituents and Albertans by not making their positions clear. Their silence is not only cowardly but also a disservice to democratic transparency.
