The Imperative of Silence for Canada's Next Governor General
As Governor General Mary Simon prepares to depart Rideau Hall, a critical conversation emerges about the proper conduct for Canada's vice-regal representatives. According to columnist Chris Selley, the fundamental requirement for any Governor General—and their spouse—should be a steadfast commitment to maintaining quiet dignity and avoiding unnecessary controversy.
Mary Simon's Mixed Legacy
Mary Simon's tenure as Governor General has been marked by both accomplishments and shortcomings. While she notably failed to fulfill her promise to learn French—a significant point of contention—she has otherwise maintained the low profile traditionally expected of the position. Her spending habits, though liberal, align with historical patterns and operate within parliamentary budgets.
"You didn't hear much from or about her, which is Job One for a governor general," Selley observes, highlighting how Simon largely succeeded in this primary duty except within francophone media circles where her linguistic limitations became a persistent source of criticism.
The Linguistic Controversy Reignited
The anglophone press outside Quebec has further complicated matters by defending Simon's bilingualism in English and Inuktitut, inadvertently creating additional friction with Quebec nationalists. This situation underscores Canada's delicate linguistic balance, where official bilingualism remains both a constitutional reality and a historical necessity for national unity.
Unfortunately, Simon's husband, former CBC journalist Whit Fraser, has chosen to exacerbate these tensions during their final days at Rideau Hall. In a recent interview with The Globe and Mail, Fraser challenged critics by asking: "How was their own lessons in Inuktitut, or Cree or Algonquin or Blackfoot or Squamish?"
This comparison between French and Indigenous languages, while perhaps well-intentioned, represents precisely the kind of provocation that Selley argues should be avoided by those associated with the vice-regal office.
The Spouse's Role and Responsibilities
While Simon cannot be held directly responsible for her husband's comments, Selley suggests that viceregal consorts bear implied duties similar to those of the Governor General themselves. As an Order of Canada recipient, Fraser arguably has an obligation to avoid "poking bears" and creating unnecessary controversy.
The situation highlights a broader question about the expectations placed on vice-regal families and their role in maintaining the dignity and neutrality of the office.
Fraser's Broader Criticisms
Beyond the linguistic debate, Fraser has used his platform to criticize modern journalism practices. In his memoir "From Ragged Ass Road to Rideau Hall," he laments what he perceives as declining standards in the media industry.
"The traditions, rules, and ethics in newsrooms where I learned my 'craft' were well understood," Fraser writes, contrasting past accountability with what he views as contemporary impunity for misinformation.
Interestingly, Fraser specifically targets National Post for reporting on the "outrageous" catering costs during Simon's 2022 Middle East trip—costs he acknowledges the public has a right to know about, despite his objections to the coverage.
Looking Forward to a Quieter Future
As Canada prepares for a new Governor General, Selley's argument centers on the importance of discretion and restraint. The vice-regal position serves as a unifying symbol above political and linguistic divisions, making silence not just a preference but a necessity.
The next occupant of Rideau Hall—and their spouse—would do well to remember that in Canada's delicate constitutional monarchy, sometimes the most powerful statement is the one never made.
