Psychologist's 'Holding Box' Method Helps Overcome Clutter Paralysis
Psychologist's 'Holding Box' Method for Decluttering

Finding the Sweet Spot Between Minimalism and Sentimentality in Spring Cleaning

The arrival of spring brings sunshine, birdsong, and the inevitable urge to refresh our living spaces. After a cozy winter, many find themselves surrounded by accumulated clutter, prompting the annual ritual of spring cleaning. However, letting go of possessions is not a one-size-fits-all process. Individuals fall on a wide spectrum, from extreme minimalists who effortlessly discard items to those who attach deep emotional significance to every object, from childhood memorabilia to family heirlooms.

The 'Holding Box' Method: A Psychological Tool for Decluttering

To navigate this challenge, Anita Yokota, a psychologist turned interior designer and author of Grounded Living: Harmonizing Design and Nature in the Home, introduced a practical technique called the 'holding box' method. Yokota, who focuses on integrating wellness into home design, explained that sentimental items often create ambivalence. "When it comes to sentimental things, there's an ambivalence," she stated. "There's this time that we really need to let it marinate."

Her method involves placing items that evoke mixed feelings into a physical box for a limited period, typically 24 to 48 hours. This creates both a physical and mental container, allowing individuals to process their emotional connections without prolonged indecision. Yokota emphasized that this timeframe is crucial: it provides enough opportunity to reflect but prevents overthinking or impulsive decisions. "It's the messy middle. We want to get from A to Z, just like that. And as you know, life is rarely black and white," she noted, highlighting how this approach acknowledges the emotional complexity of decluttering.

Wide Pickt banner — collaborative shopping lists app for Telegram, phone mockup with grocery list

Additional Decluttering Strategies: The 'Poop Question' and 'Ex Test'

Beyond the holding box, other creative tools can aid in decision-making. Co-host Noah Michelson shared the 'poop question': when unsure about keeping an item, ask yourself if you would still want it if it had feces on it. If the answer is no, it might be time to let go. Similarly, the 'ex test' involves considering whether you would go through the trouble of contacting an ex-partner to retrieve an item, such as a pair of jeans. These questions help cut through emotional attachments by introducing practical scenarios.

The Connection Between Clutter and Mental Well-being

Yokota stressed the profound link between our living environments and mental health. Excessive clutter or, in some cases, too little personalization can impact daily moods and long-term psychological well-being. Her work underscores that decluttering is not just about physical space but also about creating mental clarity. By using methods like the holding box, individuals can overcome uncertainty and make decisions that foster a harmonious home environment.

In related discussions, Yokota explored the neuroscience behind clutter's effects, how childhood experiences shape our attitudes toward mess, and which rooms to prioritize when decluttering. These insights emphasize that a thoughtful approach to organization can enhance overall wellness, making spring cleaning a valuable opportunity for both home and mind renewal.

Pickt after-article banner — collaborative shopping lists app with family illustration