In a stunning revelation that has reignited debate about Canada's trade strategy, former U.S. President Donald Trump claims that Mark Carney, then-Governor of the Bank of Canada, personally apologized for Ontario's controversial anti-tariff advertising campaign during their encounter at the G20 summit in Japan.
The Controversial Advertising Campaign
The dispute centers around Ontario's provocative "No New NAFTA Deal, No Thanks" advertising blitz, which targeted American audiences during tense trade negotiations. The campaign, funded by provincial taxpayers, directly criticized Trump's administration and its trade policies, creating significant diplomatic friction between the two nations.
Trump's Bombshell Allegation
According to Trump's account, the apology occurred during the June 2019 G20 summit in Osaka, where world leaders gathered to discuss global economic issues. "He came up to me and apologized for the ads," Trump stated, suggesting the former central bank governor expressed regret for the provincial government's aggressive marketing approach.
The timing of this alleged apology is particularly significant, as it occurred during critical moments in the renegotiation of the North American Free Trade Agreement, which would eventually become the USMCA.
Political Fallout and Reactions
The revelation has sparked immediate reactions across the political spectrum:
- Conservative critics have questioned the appropriateness of a Bank of Canada governor engaging in what appears to be political damage control
- Trade experts are debating whether such interventions help or hinder Canada's negotiating position
- Provincial officials have maintained their defense of the advertising campaign as necessary to protect Ontario's economic interests
Broader Implications for Canada-US Relations
This incident sheds light on the complex dynamics of Canada-US relations during the Trump administration. The behind-the-scenes diplomacy reveals how Canadian officials navigated the challenging political landscape while attempting to protect vital trade relationships.
The episode also raises questions about the coordination between different levels of Canadian government in international trade matters and how public messaging aligns with private diplomatic efforts.
