United We Stand: Why Alberta's Future Depends on Canadian Unity
In a compelling reflection on contemporary Canadian politics, Karen Brookman, President and CEO of Calgary-based WCD, draws upon ancient wisdom to address modern challenges. The timeless fable of the unbreakable bundle of sticks serves as a powerful metaphor for Alberta's current situation within Confederation. Brookman's analysis comes at a critical juncture when discussions about Alberta's place in Canada have reached unprecedented intensity.
The Economic Imperative of National Unity
Brookman, a lifelong Albertan, presents a nuanced perspective shaped by personal experience with federal policies that have sometimes prioritized ideology over practical economic considerations. She observes that these approaches have generated significant frustration and economic damage within her home province while simultaneously weakening Canada's overall position on the global stage. Despite these challenges, she maintains unwavering support for a united Canada where provinces collaborate effectively to dismantle trade barriers and stimulate economic growth.
The business leader emphasizes that Canada's prosperity depends on positioning the nation as an attractive and trusted global trading partner. This requires coordinated efforts across provincial boundaries and a shared commitment to national success. Brookman's perspective reflects the concerns of many business leaders who recognize that internal divisions ultimately undermine Canada's competitive advantage in international markets.
A Changing Political Landscape
Despite acknowledging past difficulties, Brookman identifies promising developments in Canada's political environment. She notes that under Mark Carney's federal leadership, Canadians are hearing more pragmatic and economically grounded messaging. This shift toward practical governance was particularly evident in Carney's unifying address at the recent World Economic Forum in Davos, which struck a courageous tone focused on national cohesion.
Simultaneously, Brookman highlights external factors that have created renewed urgency for Canadian sovereignty protection. The erosion of trust with the United States, combined with volatile global trade policies and economic pressures from international partners, has served as what she describes as a long-overdue wake-up call for the nation. This context makes provincial unity more crucial than ever for charting a resilient path forward.
The Dangers of Separatist Rhetoric
Brookman issues a stark warning about the Alberta separatist movement, characterizing it as playing with fire with potentially severe consequences. While some proponents frame separatist rhetoric as merely a negotiating tactic similar to Quebec's historical position, Brookman cautions that such approaches carry significant risks. Markets closely monitor political stability, and separatist discussions inevitably influence investor confidence and economic decisions.
Once separation enters political discourse, it raises fundamental questions about where such divisions might ultimately lead. Brookman questions whether separatism might eventually fracture Alberta itself, undermining the provincial unity that has sustained the region through generations of economic cycles. She further questions whether such discussions might discourage precisely the investment Alberta needs during challenging economic periods.
The Practical Realities of Landlocked Economics
Brookman presents compelling economic data that underscores the practical challenges facing landlocked regions. Globally, approximately forty landlocked countries experience significantly higher trade costs—typically thirty to fifty percent greater than coastal nations—due to their dependence on external ports and transportation corridors. These regions also face slower economic growth and must rely on their neighbors' political goodwill for trade access.
Brookman poses critical questions about whether Alberta truly wants to pursue this challenging path. Would separation actually increase dependence on external partners rather than fostering independence? Is there a realistic possibility that weakening Canada might ultimately lead to Alberta's economic absorption by the United States? These considerations form the foundation of her argument against separatism.
Strength Through Partnership
Ultimately, Brookman concludes that Alberta's strength lies firmly within Canada. Remaining part of Confederation provides access to essential ports, global markets, international trade agreements, and capital that would be far more difficult to secure independently. While she acknowledges the need for improved infrastructure, faster regulatory approvals, policy alignment, and regulatory reform, she maintains that these challenges should be addressed through collaboration rather than separation.
Brookman's perspective represents a thoughtful contribution to one of Canada's most pressing contemporary debates. Her business background informs a practical assessment of the economic realities facing Alberta and the nation as a whole. As discussions about provincial rights and national unity continue to evolve, her emphasis on cooperation and shared prosperity offers a compelling vision for Canada's future.
