The Edmonton Oilers face a critical decision in net as they seek a reliable goaltending partner for Tristan Jarry. With Jarry's $5.4-million average annual value contract for two more years considered untradeable, the team must explore internal options. One intriguing possibility is bringing back unrestricted free agent Connor Ingram.
Ingram's Performance and Potential
Ingram, 29, posted a 2.60 goals-against average and .899 save percentage in 32 games last season. While his career numbers sit at a 3.86 goals-against average and .876 save percentage, his recent play suggests improvement. A raise to around $2.5 million for two to three years could create a tandem with Jarry, each playing roughly 40 games, keeping total goaltending costs near $8 million.
Weak Free-Agent Market
This summer's free-agent and trade pool is notably thin. Kevin Woodley, managing editor of InGoal magazine, notes that Ingram had the best adjusted save percentage in the NHL last season. "Keeping what they have, compared to what's available to buy out there, might be the best idea," Woodley said. He advocates for a tandem approach, playing goalies every second night to alleviate internal pressure.
Defensive Struggles
Woodley also emphasizes that goaltending issues stem from team defense. The Oilers ranked 23rd defensively last season, a drop from ninth in 2024-25 and top-five in 2023-24. "There are very few goaltenders that can bail a team out that defends as poorly as the Oilers," he added. Without improved checking and defensive commitment, any goaltender will struggle.
The Oilers must decide whether to re-sign Ingram or explore other options, but given the market constraints, retaining him appears a sensible move.
