In a strategic move that could redefine his market value, star infielder Bo Bichette has signaled a significant shift in his free agency demands. According to a report from MLB.com's John Feinsand on Wednesday, December 17, 2025, Bichette and his representatives have informed interested MLB teams that the former Toronto Blue Jays shortstop is now open to playing second base on a full-time basis for his next club.
A Change of Heart for the All-Star Infielder
For years, Bichette maintained a firm stance that shortstop was his position, especially during his prime. However, the dynamics of free agency and team evaluations have prompted a notable pivot. "It seems like the message has gotten through to him that teams don't view him as a shortstop in the long-term — or maybe even in 2026," a source told Feinsand. "His willingness to change positions can only help him in the market."
This new flexibility is seen as a direct response to how potential suitors value his defensive capabilities. While his bat has never been in question—Bichette batted .311 in 2025 and was second in the majors in both doubles (44) and hits (181)—his glove at shortstop has been a topic of debate. His brief but competent stint at second base during the 2025 World Series, following a September knee injury, may have demonstrated his adaptability and softened his own stance.
What This Means for the Toronto Blue Jays
The development adds a fascinating layer to the Blue Jays' offseason strategy. General Manager Ross Atkins has previously stated the team is "in his market," but the extent of Toronto's pursuit has been unclear. If Bichette is no longer insisting on playing shortstop, a return to Toronto becomes logistically smoother.
He could seamlessly slide in at second, allowing Andres Gimenez—who filled in admirably after Bichette's injury—to remain the everyday shortstop. Re-signing Bichette would reunite him with Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and address the team's remaining need for an impact bat, alongside their reported interest in outfielder Kyle Tucker.
Expanding the Free Agent Market
Bichette's positional openness is a calculated move that could significantly broaden his list of suitors. Historically, shortstops command higher salaries due to the premium defensive value of the position. By being willing to move to second, Bichette removes a potential barrier for teams that have a franchise shortstop but need offensive firepower in the middle infield.
This could make him attractive to a wider array of contenders, including the Boston Red Sox, New York Yankees, Atlanta Braves, and Los Angeles Dodgers, all teams he has been linked to. The strategy suggests his camp may believe the market for second basemen is deeper or that removing the "shortstop-only" label creates more competition for his elite bat.
As the offseason continues, all eyes will be on where one of baseball's most potent hitters lands, with his newfound flexibility now a central part of the negotiation.
