If you have been hesitant to purchase EltaMD's UV Clear broad-spectrum face sunscreen with SPF 46 due to its $45 price tag, you are not alone. Fortunately, an affordable alternative has emerged that delivers comparable quality. Drmtlgy's SmrtSun broad-spectrum SPF 45 sunscreen has garnered a loyal following among former EltaMD users, who claim it performs just as well for $17 less.
Price Comparison
Drmtlgy SmrtSun is available for $28 at Ulta or $22 directly from Drmtlgy (regularly $28). In contrast, EltaMD UV Clear costs $45 at Amazon. This makes Drmtlgy less than two-thirds the price of its competitor.
Ingredient Similarities
Both sunscreens contain zinc oxide and 7.5% octinoxate as UV filters. Notably, Drmtlgy has a higher zinc oxide concentration at 12%, compared to EltaMD's 9%. Additional shared ingredients include hyaluronic acid for hydration, niacinamide for even skin tone, and tocopheryl acetate (vitamin E), an antioxidant that may reduce signs of aging.
User Reviews
Many reviewers who have used both products prefer Drmtlgy not only for its price but also for its skin feel. One Ulta reviewer stated, "This sunscreen has replaced my EltaMD UV Clear as my holy grail. This is the first sunscreen that I have WANTED to put on." Another claimed it performs even better, noting that it wears well under makeup without pilling.
Users describe the formula as non-greasy, lightweight, and hydrating without leaving a white cast. "It goes on smoothly and soaks in. Doesn't feel like it's just sitting on my face," said one shopper. Another noticed improvements in skin brightness and tone after a month of use.
The sunscreen is also recommended by skin cancer survivors. One reviewer with sensitive skin and a history of skin cancer called it her go-to daily SPF, praising its non-irritating formula and lack of odor. Another user, diagnosed with skin cancer in 2021, finally found a sunscreen that works for her, applying it to her face, décolleté, and arms.
Additional Recommendations
For those seeking more options, dermatologists recommend:
- EltaMD UV Clear SPF 46 – A cult-favorite mineral SPF with hyaluronic acid and lactic acid, ideal for sensitive and acne-prone skin. $45 at Dermstore or Amazon.
- CeraVe AM Facial Moisturizing Lotion with SPF 30 – An affordable option with ceramides, hyaluronic acid, and niacinamide, suitable for daily use. $15 at Amazon, Ulta, or Target.
- Blue Lizard Sensitive Mineral Sunscreen SPF 50+ – A reef-safe, water-resistant option for outdoor activities. $14 at Ulta.
If EltaMD UV Clear is not within your budget, Drmtlgy SmrtSun offers a compelling alternative that protects and nourishes the skin without breaking the bank.
