Warren Kinsella, a columnist for the Toronto Sun, has delivered a scathing critique of Alberta Premier Danielle Smith's plan to hold a referendum on whether Alberta should remain part of Canada. In his article, Kinsella, who identifies as an Albertan and a staunch opponent of separatism, argues that Smith's gambit will not break up Canada but will likely end her political career.
Personal History with Separatism
Kinsella recounts his family's forced departure from Quebec in the 1970s due to separatist sentiment, which targeted English speakers. He notes that Quebec's two referendums on separation caused significant economic damage, with over 700 companies leaving the province and billions in losses. He contrasts this with former Alberta Premier Peter Lougheed, who fought for Alberta's interests within Canada.
Critique of Danielle Smith
Kinsella, who attended the same high school as Smith, describes her as not particularly smart and robotic in her public appearances. He criticizes her recent announcement of a referendum question: "Should Alberta remain a province of Canada or should the Government of Alberta commence the legal process required under the Canadian Constitution to hold a binding provincial referendum on whether or not Alberta should separate from Canada?" He argues that this 37-word question will cause widespread unhappiness.
Reactions from Various Groups
- Alberta separatists: They are livid because they wanted a direct vote on leaving Canada now, not a referendum on a future referendum. They have vowed to oust Smith.
- Pro-Canada advocates: They denounce Smith for causing economic damage and political uncertainty.
- National leaders: Prime Minister Mark Carney, who was raised in Alberta, is displeased after Smith undermined a historic pipeline deal. Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre, also from Alberta, has promised to campaign against the referendum.
- First Nations: They are outraged that Smith has not meaningfully consulted them, as required by the constitution, and have threatened legal action.
External Influences
Kinsella highlights that Russian covert networks and MAGA Republicans are supporting the separatist movement. He warns that U.S. President Donald Trump may soon promote Alberta independence, as his allies have secretly met with separatists.
Conclusion
Kinsella predicts that Smith's gambit will cause chaos and uncertainty, bringing back divisive constitutional debates. He concludes that while Canada will survive, Smith's premiership will not. The article ends with a call to support local journalism and a note that this content is reserved for subscribers.
